AltDrive Electric Powertrain Menu
Battery-electric/diesel hybrid drivetrains are often considered a ‘first step’ on the path to full electrification. That can be true if 100% electrification is the goal. But both hybrid and battery-electric drivetrains have their ideal use cases, depending on your aims and the machine’s duty cycle.
While both battery-only and battery-electric/diesel hybrid are viable paths toward reducing diesel consumption, emissions and operating costs in heavy industrial equipment, the two approaches differ significantly in architecture, energy management, infrastructure requirements and operational flexibility.
Choosing between them is not simply a matter of electrifying a machine. The optimal solution depends on how energy is consumed, recovered, stored and replenished throughout the operating cycle.
Full Battery-Electric Drivetrains
The power in a full battery-electric drivetrain is supplied exclusively by onboard batteries, which are charged by means of an onboard or (more commonly) external charger. In heavy-duty industrial applications, both hybrid and full battery-electric platforms typically include:
- Battery energy storage
- Electric traction motors
- Inverters and motor controllers
- Thermal management systems
- Vehicle control systems
Full battery-electric drivetrains also often include onboard charging hardware, while hybrid systems can be configured to use the diesel engine to charge batteries.
Electric motors deliver instantaneous torque and precise control characteristics that can improve productivity in many industrial applications. However, full battery-electric operation introduces quite a few engineering considerations: battery capacity must support the required duty cycle and charging windows must align with operations.
Charging infrastructure must typically be installed at the worksite. All that battery means that the machine’s thermal management requirements increase substantially and vehicle weight and packaging constraints become critical, since batteries are heavier and take up more space than diesel per unit of energy delivered.
Full battery-electric systems are best suited to applications with predictable operating cycles, access to charging infrastructure and the downtime intervals required for charging.
Battery-electric/diesel hybrid drivetrains
Battery-electric/diesel hybrid drivetrains combine electric propulsion systems with an onboard diesel power source that most often operates primarily, or exclusively, as a generator that charges the batteries. But that is not always the case. MEDATech has designed and built a hybrid drivetrain that can harness both diesel and battery power for high power-demand situations. That vehicle can also run on battery only, or diesel only.
When the diesel engine is used as a generator rather than for handling peak loads, it can operate within a more efficient RPM range while electric motors handle transient loads and propulsion demands.
A hybrid drivetrain generally includes:
- Battery energy storage
- Electric traction motors
- Inverters and motor controllers
- Thermal management systems
- Vehicle control systems
- Diesel generator set
- Energy management controls
- Regenerative energy recovery systems
Unlike conventional mechanical drivetrains, hybrid systems decouple engine speed from wheel or hydraulic demand. This creates opportunities to optimize engine efficiency, reduce fuel burn and recover energy that would otherwise be lost. Hybrid systems are also normally configured to reduce dependence on charging infrastructure by generating electric power onboard.
Key Technical Differences
Because all usable energy must be stored in batteries, the vehicle range and productivity of a battery-electric machine are therefore constrained by battery capacity and charging availability. In a hybrid drivetrain, the battery functions more as a dynamic energy buffer than as the sole energy source.
This difference affects several aspects of system design:
- Battery-electric systems generally require significantly larger battery packs to sustain long operating periods.
- By eliminating the internal combustion engine entirely, battery-electric systems simplify some mechanical systems as well as maintenance requirements.
- Hybrid systems reduce infrastructure dependency while still delivering many advantages associated with electrified drivetrains.
\Battery-electric systems can perform extremely effectively where charging infrastructure is reliable and operational cycles are well aligned with charging opportunities. Sophisticated plug-and-play hybrid systems, on the other hand, are often more adaptable in remote or infrastructure-limited environments where charging access is constrained or inconsistent.
What system suits your needs best?
In some cases, a full battery-electric platform delivers the greatest operational and environmental advantages. In others, hybridization provides a more practical balance between electrification benefits, infrastructure requirements, operational uptime and capital cost. The appropriate solution depends entirely on the application, operating profile, site constraints and project objectives.
The best way to determine the ideal drivetrain for your needs, both source of power and configuration, is through analysis of current or modelled operating data, energy demand profiles, vehicle integration requirements and site conditions. In other words, a feasibility study.